Sea Screamer vs Sea Thunder – Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

When it comes to US seaside destinations, tourists are often presented with several options when it comes to Dolphin and Whale Sighting cruises.  This is true of Virginia Beach (Virginia), Outer Banks (North Carolina), Clearwater, Fort Lauderdale, Miami, and Key West (Florida), as well as San Diego and Newport Beach (California) and the list goes on.

So, it stands to reason that a tourist mecca such as Myrtle Beach, South Carolina would have numerous tours to choose from as well.   And they do!

Two of the most popular cruises are with sister boats – Sea Thunder and Sea Screamer, both of which depart from locations north of North Myrtle Beach.  Travelers might be familiar with Sea Screamer’s other locations – currently in Clearwater, Florida and their former locations that included Miami, Florida and Toronto, Canada.  Of course, the Toronto franchise did not offer dolphin sightings; it was more of a scenic tour of the harbor followed by a thrill ride on Lake Ontario.

Been Here Done That reviewers have, at one time or another, have taken cruises on ALL boats in the Sea Screamer fleet (including the defunct locations), and recently have enjoyed a cruise aboard the Sea Thunder as well. Consequently, we feel qualified to compare both experiences.

Sea Thunder and Sea Screamer have much in common, including: 

  • Both hold 149 passengers and 3 crew members.
  • Both are 65 feet long and 20 feet wide with 2 restrooms on board.
  • Cruises are both 1.5 – 2 hours long.
  • Tickets Prices are identical (and reasonable) with adult tickets at $25.00 and children (3-12) at $15.00. Under 2 is free.  Booking online yields a $3 discount on tickets.  A printable coupon is available on the site, for $3.00 off each ticket in your party should you choose to purchase tickets in person.
  • During peak season these tours are full so reservations are recommended.
  • Scheduling is identical with cruises starting in the month of April and ending in October of each year, with 1 cruise per day during the offseason and 3 cruises per day during peak season
  • The route up the Intracoastal Waterway and out to the ocean is the same, thus the scenery and points of interest are identical.
  • Based on the same route, the narrated portion of the tour is very similar.
  • The objective of a slow, narrated tour on the waterway, followed by a casual dolphin watch, followed by a fast and thrilling ride through the ocean, is the same.
  • Passengers will get wet on both boats.

The differences aren’t many but they include:

  • No cover, thus no shade on the Sea Screamer – 50% covered on the Sea Thunder.
  • 111 bucket seats and 38 bench seats on the Sea Screamer – 4 bucket seats and 145 bench seats on the Sea Thunder.
  • 1500 Horse Power on the Sea Screamer – 2100 Horse Power on the Sea Thunder.
  • Sea Screamer is docked at Little River, Sea Thunder is docked at Cherry Grove, thus creating an 8-minute difference in cruise time on the Intracoastal Waterway before reaching the mouth of the ocean.

For the calm Intracoastal Waterway portion of the tour, guests are treated to views of beautiful residential properties, restaurant patios that overlook the water, golf courses that stretch to the water’s edge, jet skis and boats of all kinds including a massive floating casino that offers nighttime tours.  As well, there is much in the way of indigenous birds, animals, and plants.  Narration includes information about the civil war and some properties that date back to that time period.  Bear in mind that it doesn’t matter on which side of the boat you sit because you will catch whatever you missed when the boat turns around for the return trip to the dock.

The ride becomes choppy as you reach the churning white water at the mouth of the ocean, but certainly not enough that guests need to be concerned about motion sickness.  And it doesn’t last long.  Very soon the boat is cruising through rolling waves while guests enjoy views of the beach and sand dunes, with North Myrtle Beach and all of its resorts in the distance.

From there, the casual dolphin watch begins and almost always entails a jaunt out to a shrimp boat or fishing trawler.  It’s there that most cruises are lucky enough to spot a pod of dolphins while feasting on scraps of fish.  However, if this is not the case for your cruise, the Sea Screamer and Sea Thunder both offer a free pass to ride again.  You can use the pass to ride the same boat or opt for the sister boat for a slightly different experience.

Then it’s time for the speed portion of the cruise through the open ocean, pushing the boat’s horsepower to deliver maximum excitement.  This is the portion of the tour that will cause guests to get wet! It’s also where the boats differ somewhat.

Although the Sea Screamer has less horsepower, the boat feels lighter and far more agile, causing it to soar across the water and crash through waves with a force capable of bouncing riders off their bucket seats. To be honest, our BHDT reviewers felt that Sea Screamer was far faster and much better at delivering a thrill than the Sea Thunder. Guests at the front of the boat receive a thorough soaking, whereas seats further to the back are spared somewhat.  If you’re seated at the sides, there’s still considerable splash, but not nearly as extensive as up front.

Though the Sea Thunder technically possesses more power, the boat is heavier so the speed is still impressive but the ride is less aggressive. Guests will experience some jostling but they are unlikely to be bounced off the bench seats.  Riders at the front of the boat will get drenched, as will riders seated at the sides.  However, for the most part, seats toward the back and middle of the boat are spared.

It bears mentioning that, if you suffer from back or neck problems, the cruise might not be wise on either boat.

The excursion will certainly produce plenty of photo opportunities so don’t forget to take your camera or smartphone.  Also, we found that a little planning and preparation goes a long way so we recommend arriving early for your tour considering guests line-up on the dock and those at the front of the line have the first choice of seats.  We also recommend eating something before you go because the limited snacks and drinks that are offered aboard the boats are indeed expensive.

Don’t forget to take sunscreen and sunglasses, and perhaps a hat as well considering you’ll have 2 hours of direct sun on your head.  Even those seated in the covered section of Sea Thunder will encounter the sun on their right or left side. You also might want to think about taking a towel and/or a change of clothes in case you get soaked to the bone.  If you don’t want to take them onboard lest they get wet as well, simply leave a bag or knapsack of supplies in the trunk of your car. And when it comes to your electronics, whether it’s your smartphone, camera or video equipment, be sure to protect them by taking a weatherproof bag so you can stash everything inside during the high-speed portion of the cruise.

No matter which boat you choose to cruise on, we’re sure you will enjoy your trip. It probably won’t be something you will do again and again, but if you’re a first-timer in Myrtle Beach, we think this tour should not be missed.

For more information or to book a cruise, click HERE

 

Share This Post:

5 thoughts on “Sea Screamer vs Sea Thunder – Myrtle Beach, South Carolina

  • May 15, 2017 at 8:03 am
    Permalink

    Wonderful post. With so many cruises in the area it’s hard to know which is best. Thanks for sharing.

    Reply
  • July 5, 2017 at 12:40 am
    Permalink

    I really like your articles, superb info.

    Reply
  • August 26, 2017 at 6:17 pm
    Permalink

    Hi thеre! I just want to give you a big thumbs up for this information. I wondered how much of a difference there was in the boats.

    Reply
  • August 4, 2018 at 9:59 am
    Permalink

    My family was there the last week of July. We did not see dolphins but my kids loved the sea screamer, the crew was amazing. I have 2 children 7 and 3, they loved everything about this and they got soaked. The ocean was really rough that week. But please if you have the chance to go on these boats please do so it was amazing. Also if you have time to spare have some cake from inside the restaurant it was amazing. Thank you sea screamer for a fun day with my family

    Reply
    • August 5, 2018 at 8:52 am
      Permalink

      Hello Paula,

      Yes, it is a great attraction and a lot of fun for both kids and adults. Our reviewers have been on the Sea Screamer and Sea Thunder in order to write this comparative article/review. The Sea Thunder was the most recent ride, August 2 years ago. As we mentioned in the review, if passengers fail to see any dolphins, you can ask for a free pass to go on a second cruise (on either boat) and try again. So perhaps you could have tried that. According to their website, the offer still stands.

      As for thanking Sea Screamer, perhaps you should do so on their website at https://www.myrtlebeachdolphincruises.com/ as we are not Sea Screamer, we are Been Here Done That Magazine and offer travel reviews of hotels, attractions, and dining.

      Thanks for stopping by and commenting. We appreciate it.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *